When browsing handwritten manuscripts, my eye is always drawn to recipes with unusual titles. Whether it’s someone’s name, or a location, or as in this case, an odd title.
To be honest, after reading it, I wasn’t sure why this pudding is incomprehensible. There are only a few ingredients – none of them unusual, and a straightforward method.
Then I made it and it turned out so light and delicate, it was a real surprise. At first glance, it seems like a custard, but the addition of the apple pulp, especially if you can get Bramley cooking apples, makes it almost frothy. With the use of clarified butter (where only the fat is used, and not the dairy solids), you could arguably denote this dairy-free.
It makes the perfect dessert in that it appears decadent, but can be enjoyed without the heaviness associated with a lot of puddings.
The original recipe called for puff pastry round the edge of the dish, which is something that has puzzled me for years, as it appears in many pudding recipes of this time. I can’t work out if it is for decoration only, or for consumption. I decided not to include pastry, because the high temperature required to cook it properly is at odds with the gentle heat needed to just set the custard.
I also opted for individual servings, so aimed for a shorter cooking time, because in typical 18th century style, the original cooking instructions are short and vague: “an hour will bake it”. Sometimes custard-style puddings are baked in a water bath, and in testing I did try baking it both ways, and for this serving size the difference was so slight I’m going to suggest no water bath. If you wanted to make a large serving, then yes, use a water bath to ensure the mixture cooks without curdling.
I’ve scaled the recipe down to a single serving size. You can scale it up as required.
The puddings in the photo are served plain, but you could also opt to sprinkle them with sugar and blowtorch/grill them to caramelise the top.
Incomprehensible Pudding for One
120g unsweetened apple pulp
1 large egg
20g liquid clarified butter
20g caster sugar
extra caster sugar or brulée sugar
- Heat the oven to 150°C, 130°C Fan.
- Whisk the egg and sugar until pale and frothy.
- Add the apple and butter and mix until smooth.
- Pour mixture into a shallow dish and bake for 20 minutes until almost set (slightly wobbly in the centre).
- Remove from the oven and allow to cool to room temperature.
- (Optional) Sprinkle with caster sugar (or brulée sugar) and brulee with either blowtorch or grill.
3 thoughts on “Incomprehensible Pudding”
Maybe I’m being a bit dim, but what do you mean by ‘apple pulp’? Thanks.
Its peeled, cored and chopped cooking apples that are briefly cooked with a little water until they break down and can be sieved.
Hope this helps!
Quick and easy, my kind of recipe, Mary Anne