This is going to be the newest recipe on here, because I just made it up!
Well, not to claim all the credit – it is a Lego™ recipe in that I’ve cherry-picked a bit from here and a bit from there and brought it together into something absolutely delicious. As a bonus, it can be made with just a few storecupboard ingredients.
It struck me recently that there are no 21st century recipes here – indeed, there wasn’t even a 21st century category until I added one just now. I don’t want this blog to become a museum to British food, rather for it to be an ongoing celebration of British food that ranges across centuries, including this one.
This recipe pays homage to recipes that date back to Days of Yore (a very technical term in food history circles, which means quite a number of years ago!). Poor Knights of Windsor, Fried Cream, Fried Toasts and Pain Perdu are all similar dishes and all have long pedigrees in British food. Eggs, bread, sugar and cream, together with some spices and flavourings, sometimes even a splash of alcohol, have been tweaked and teased into subtly different, but equally enjoyable, dishes for centuries.
This recipe is also similar to several dishes ‘out there’ because, as we know, there’s nothing new under the sun. I’ve done some fairly rigorous searching and there isn’t anything out there exactly like this, but if I have missed something, be sure to let me know.
It was inspired by a dish I saw recently on television, specifically a caramelised French Toast, served in a restaurant in the Basque region in Spain: the smooth shiny, crisp outside a stark contrast with the soft, creamy insides. The local name for these fried milk toasts is Torrijas. Rather that slices, I decided to make toast fingers and roll them in panko breadcrumbs for contrasting crunch, because everything tastes better with crunch!
You can make simplified versions of this, according to your cupboard contents, but I’m just going to run through the method I used and the reasons behind it, so you can make your own decisions.
The Bread: Unsliced white bread. For a start, in these modern, health-conscious times, white bread is so NORTY, which makes it taste doubly delicious when used for a treat such as this. You can make your own, which has its advantages in that it holds up better during the soaking in the milk. However, a BOUGHTEN white loaf from the bakery retains its feather lightness incredibly, if you’re willing to be patient in the handling/preparation. It helps if you stale the bread a little before the soaking, as that will help keep it from falling apart. More on this below.
The Milk: A mixture of condensed milk and fresh milk gives both sweetness and richness. Also, keeping a tin on hand in the cupboard makes these an anytime snack. You could also mix your own combination of sugars and fresh cream/milk. Just ensure your mixture is fluid enough to soak into the bread.
The Flavourings. Whatever takes your fancy, really. I infused the milk with some citrus zest and then added a generous splash of vanilla and orange-flower water. It makes for a very creamy aroma, if that makes any sense.
The Coating: Breadcrumbs, Japanese Panko-style for preference. It forms a crisp, golden shell around the soft pillowy bread and looks very appetising when cooked and golden brown. My local supermarket (the orange one) has recently started selling large bags of panko breadcrumbs in the Japanese Foods section of the International Foods aisle. Great value for money and perfect for this recipe. Also, I prefer to use eggwhites for coating, as I believe it helps give crispness.
The Frying: Again, whatever takes your fancy. I used Indian ghee (clarified butter), as I didn’t want the milk solids from regular butter to catch in the pan and spoil the breadcrumb coating with dark flecks. You could also use oil, or even deep-fry them if you have a fryer. Alas, mine is currently filled with beef dripping, which is flavoursome for savoury dishes, but not so suitable for this sweet treat.
Cream Toasts
These quantities will make several servings, so if you’re not going to use it up all at once, keep the extra milk in the fridge for later use.
white loaf of bread
280ml milk – whole, skimmed, whatever you have
zest of 1 lemon
1tsp orange flower water (optional)
1tsp vanilla flavouring (optional)
1 tin sweetened condensed milk (397ml)
eggwhites for coating
panko breadcrumbs for coating
ghee, butter or oil for frying
sharp, seedless jam (raspberry/redcurrant/cranberry) or coulis to serve
- Remove the crusts from the loaf and set aside for crust sandwiches.
- Cut the bread ino 3cm slices, then cut each slice into 3 x 3cm fingers. Arrange the bread fingers on a wire cooling rack to stale for about an hour. This can be done beforehand.
- Put the milk into a small pan and add the lemon zest.
- Bring to a gentle boil and turn off the heat.
- Cover and allow to infuse for 30 minutes.
- Strain out the lemon zest (if you prefer, I didn’t) and mix in the condensed milk and other flavourings until well combined. Set aside.
- Pour a little of the milk mixture into a plastic box.
- Arrange the slightly stale bread fingers in the box, then pour over the rest of the milk mixture. Leave to soak for 5 minutes.
- Carefully turn the bread fingers over and allow to soak for another 5 minutes.
- Drain off the excess milk and put the plastic box into the fridge – uncovered – for an hour or two. This will allow the outside of the bread fingers to dry a little. If you’re wanting to make these for breakfast you can do everything up to this point the night before, and then continue in the morning. If leaving overnight, cover the box lightly in cling film so that it doesn’t dry out too much.
- When ready to cook, pour some eggwhite into a plastic box and the panko breadcrumbs onto a shallow tray.
- Whisk the eggwhites briefly until frothy.
- Carefully take each soaked bread finger and coat with eggwhite. Since they will be rather delicate, I usually drop them into the eggwhite one by one and then shake the box from side to side and get the eggwhite to wash over them that way.
- Lift out and let the excess eggwhite drain off, then lay them in the panko breadcrumbs.
- Pat the panko onto the bread fingers until thoroughly coated.
- Set aside onto a plate until ready to be cooked.
- Heat the fat you are using in a small pan on medium heat. I use 6 on a scale of 1-9. If you use a small pan and can make your fat/oil 2cm deep, you’ll only need to turn your cream toasts once. If it’s shallower, you may need to fry each side individually.
- Fry 3 or 4 fingers in the pan at a time. Cook until the panko coating is crisp and golden.
- While they are cooking, set out a wire cooling rack, with a sheet of kitchen roll underneath it.
- When cooked, transfer the now golden brown toasts to the wire rack and allow to drain.
- Serve warm with a pot of jam/coulis for dipping.
Bonus recipe – Crispy Eggy Bread

This same method can be used to jazz-up a personal favourite of mine – Eggy Bread. This is a savoury version of egg-soaked bread, and one which I enjoyed for breakfast as a child and still do to this day.
This recipe is more easily scaled than the one above, as it can be made in a per-person quantity.
The home-made loaf I made suited this recipe better than store bought.
Crispy Eggy Bread for One
1 x 3cm thick slice of white bread
1 large egg
salt and pepper to taste
eggwhites for coating
panko breadcrumbs for coating
ghee, butter or oil for frying
tomato ketchup to serve
- Remove the crusts from the loaf and cut into 3 x 3cm fingers. Arrange the bread fingers on a wire cooling rack to stale for about an hour. This can be done beforehand.
- Whisk the egg vigorously, then pass through a sieve to make sure the white and the yolk are fully mixed.
- Season egg with salt and pepper to taste.
- Pour a little of the egg mixture into a plastic box.
- Arrange the slightly stale bread fingers in the box, then pour over the rest of the egg mixture. Leave to soak for 5 minutes.
- Carefully turn the bread fingers over and allow to soak for another 5 minutes.
- Put the plastic box into the fridge – uncovered – for an hour or two.. This will allow the outside of the bread fingers to dry a little. If you’re wanting to make these for breakfast you can do everything up to this point the night before, and then continue in the morning. If leaving overnight, cover the box lightly in cling film so that it doesn’t dry out too much.
- When ready to cook, pour some eggwhite into a plastic box and the panko breadcrumbs onto a shallow tray.
- Whisk the eggwhites briefly until frothy.
- Carefully take each soaked bread finger and coat with eggwhite. Since they will be rather delicate, I usually drop them into the eggwhite one by one and then shake the box from side to side and get the eggwhite to wash over them that way.
- Lift out and let the excess eggwhite drain off, then lay them in the panko breadcrumbs.
- Set aside onto a plate until ready to be cooked.
- Heat the fat you are using in a small pan on medium heat. I use 6 on a scale of 1-9. If you use a small pan and can make your fat/oil 2cm deep, you’ll only need to turn your eggy bread fingers once. If it’s shallower, you may need to fry each side individually.
- Fry the fingers in the pan until the panko coating is crisp and golden.
- While they are cooking, set out a wire cooling rack, with a sheet of kitchen roll underneath it.
- When cooked, transfer the now golden brown toasts to the wire rack and allow to drain.
- Serve warm with a pot of tomato ketchup for dipping.